TL;DR
Get business pricing on monitors, keyboards and dev gear
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
Apple’s Golden Gate menus no longer show an icon beside every menu item by default, reversing a design introduced with macOS Tahoe, according to Jim Nielsen’s report. Apple’s Human Interface Guidelines now cite Tahoe’s menu approach as an example of what not to do on macOS; the report does not establish when the change will reach users or whether it applies to every app.
Apple has removed icons from every menu item by default in its Golden Gate design, reversing a menu treatment introduced with macOS Tahoe, according to a report by designer Jim Nielsen. The change matters because Apple’s updated Human Interface Guidelines now point to Tahoe’s menu approach as an example of what not to do on macOS, turning a visual revision into explicit design guidance.
Nielsen’s report, published on his blog, says the Golden Gate menus no longer use an icon beside each menu item as the default. The earlier approach arrived with macOS Tahoe, where icons appeared across menus. Nielsen had criticized that practice, arguing that menus did not need a graphic next to every command.
The report says Apple’s current Human Interface Guidelines specifically identify Tahoe’s approach to menus as an example of what not to do on Mac. That is a change from merely choosing not to use menu icons: Apple is described as having shipped the design, used it for a year, and then changed its public guidance.
Nielsen says John Gruber wrote about the reversal in June, including the guidelines’ treatment of the Tahoe design. The supplied report does not give a precise date for Golden Gate’s release, identify a software build, or document how the revised menus appear across individual Apple apps. Those details limit how broadly the change can be described.
The reversal gives developers a concrete example of Apple revising its own interface decisions. The company’s guidelines can influence how Mac apps are designed, so calling the Tahoe pattern an example to avoid carries more weight than a preference expressed only by outside designers. It also gives advocates of simpler menus a clearer argument: Apple tried putting icons across menus and subsequently moved away from that default.
For people who use Mac menus, removing routine icons may make the command labels the primary visual information rather than asking users to scan a mix of labels and small graphics. That is a likely design implication, not a measured usability result in the source. Nielsen’s report does not include user testing, accessibility findings, or evidence that the change improves task speed or comprehension.
The development also illustrates that platform conventions can change after they reach users. Designers and app makers may need to distinguish between an icon that communicates a useful distinction and one added simply for consistency. The report supports the narrower point that Apple has changed its default direction; it does not say that icons are prohibited in menus or that every third-party app will change.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Tahoe to Golden Gate
The sequence described in Nielsen’s account is relatively short: macOS Tahoe introduced icons across menu items; designers and commentators criticized the choice; Apple later revised its Human Interface Guidelines; and Golden Gate is reported to have dropped icons as the default. Nielsen says the design had been in use for a year before Apple changed course.
Before Tahoe, Nielsen used Apple’s own menus as an example in arguing against icons on every item. That point became less persuasive when Apple adopted the pattern itself. He now argues that the reversal is more instructive: Apple not only reconsidered the practice but also changed its written guidance. His comments are an interpretation of the design shift, rather than an official explanation from Apple.
The source frames this as a reversal in menu design policy, not a broader removal of icons from macOS. It provides no evidence that Apple plans to remove icons from toolbars, app launchers, settings, or other interface areas. Keeping the scope to menus is important when interpreting the change.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Scope and Rollout Still Unclear
The report does not specify which Golden Gate version or build contains the revised menus, when users can expect to receive it, or whether the change is already available publicly. It also does not show whether the default applies consistently to all Apple applications or only to a particular system design.
Apple’s reasoning is not included. The source says the Human Interface Guidelines identify Tahoe’s menu treatment as an example of what not to do, but it provides no direct statement from Apple explaining the reversal, citing user feedback, or discussing accessibility and usability. It is also unclear whether developers are being asked to remove existing menu icons or simply not to add them by default.
The reported change concerns icons displayed beside menu items. It should not be read as a claim that Apple has banned menu icons altogether or removed iconography throughout macOS. The source offers no measurements showing how users responded to either design.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Watch for Release Details
The next useful confirmation would be Apple’s release documentation or a publicly available Golden Gate build showing how the menus behave across system apps. Those details could clarify the rollout, identify exceptions, and show whether developers must take action in their own software.
Until then, the supported takeaway is limited: Nielsen reports that Golden Gate no longer puts an icon beside every menu item by default and that Apple’s design guidance now treats Tahoe’s approach as one to avoid. Any broader claim about a system-wide ban, a user benefit, or Apple’s reasons would require more evidence.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
According to Jim Nielsen’s report, Golden Gate no longer displays an icon beside every menu item by default. The report does not say icons are banned in all menus.
What did macOS Tahoe do differently?
Nielsen says Tahoe introduced icons across menu items, a pattern he had criticized as unnecessary when applied to every command.
Did Apple change its design guidance?
The report says Apple’s Human Interface Guidelines now cite Tahoe’s menu approach as an example of what not to do on macOS.
When will users get the change?
The source does not provide a release date or rollout schedule for Golden Gate, so availability to users remains unclear.
Has Apple explained why it reversed the design?
No explanation from Apple is included in the report. The source does not establish whether the change followed user feedback, testing, or another design decision.
Source: hn
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
