🔍 Read the full analysis: The Connection Between AI, Spreadsheets, And Bookkeepers on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get business pricing on monitors, keyboards and dev gear
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
TL;DR
U.S. employment data show bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks declining over time while accountants and auditors grew, leaving the two groups near a one-to-one ratio in 2025. The source traces part of that change to spreadsheets and accounting software, and says the Bureau of Labor Statistics projects further clerk declines as AI takes on routine work. Those forecasts are not evidence that AI has already caused job losses.
A November 22 article from ThorstenMeyerAI.com compares the spread of spreadsheets with current forecasts for artificial intelligence, using U.S. employment data to show how bookkeeping clerk numbers have fallen while accountant and auditor numbers have grown. The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) counted about 1.53 million bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks and 1.60 million accountants and auditors in 2025; its projections anticipate further clerk declines and modest growth for accountants through 2035, but do not establish that AI has caused those changes.
The article centers on the shift from paper ledgers to spreadsheet software. In 1978, Harvard student Dan Bricklin imagined a calculator that would update an entire financial sheet when a figure changed. With programmer Bob Frankston, he developed VisiCalc, which shipped for the Apple II in 1979. Its grid let users change an input and recalculate dependent figures automatically, making financial what-if analysis faster.
In a 1984 account by writer Steven Levy, Cincinnati accountant Don Jackson said a calculation that once took him about 20 hours could be completed in 15 minutes with a spreadsheet. Jackson served roughly 40 to 50 clients, mostly small businesses. The example illustrates a specific productivity gain; it does not by itself establish how many jobs spreadsheets displaced.
The source reports that BLS figures for 1988 to 2025 show bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks declining from about 2.25 million to 1.53 million, while accountants and auditors increased from about 963,000 to 1.60 million. By 2025, the two categories were close to equal in size. The article says spreadsheets were not the only influence: accounting software also automated posting and adding, and about 1.5 million clerk jobs remained.
Infographic 01 · How the spreadsheet arrived
From the abacus to VisiCalc
Machines chased bookkeeping for decades. The spreadsheet put the calculation on every desk.
Machines and the books
- Tokyo, November 1946: an American soldier with an electric calculator against a Japanese postal worker with a soroban. The abacus won four rounds out of five (Computer History Museum).
- Nuremberg, 14 February 1966: 65 tax advisers found DATEV to do their clients’ bookkeeping by computer; the first data centre had four rented IBM mainframes at DM 245,000 a month (DATEV).
- Spring 1978: Harvard Business School student Dan Bricklin imagines a calculator that redoes a ledger sheet by itself (Bricklin).
- October 1979: VisiCalc by Bricklin and Bob Frankston ships for the Apple II. The analyst Ben Rosen: “the software tail that wags (and sells) the personal computer dog.”
- Early 1983: Lotus 1-2-3 for the IBM PC; it soon replaces VisiCalc as the leading spreadsheet (Bricklin).
- 1984: more than a million spreadsheet programs a year in the US. Levy warns: even an elegant spreadsheet is “a house of cards”.
Company and personal accounts are marked as such. The 20-hours figure is one accountant’s own account, as reported by Steven Levy.
Sources: D. Bricklin, VisiCalc history; S. Levy, Harper's, November 1984; Computer History Museum; DATEV company history.
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
Automation Changed the Accounting Job Mix
The employment comparison points to a change in the composition of accounting work, not the disappearance of bookkeeping. Routine recording and calculation became easier to automate, while the number of accountants and auditors rose over the period described. That pattern matters to workers and businesses because new tools can change which tasks are valued without eliminating the broader need to maintain financial records and interpret them.
The historical example also helps put claims about AI in perspective. A spreadsheet could reduce the time needed to recalculate a ledger, but the source does not isolate its effect from other changes in technology, business activity or occupational classification. Similarly, forecasts that AI may take on data entry are not proof that the technology has already reduced employment. The distinction between a task being automated and a whole occupation disappearing is central to understanding the projections.
Products Worth Considering

Samsung 32 Odyssey G5 QHD Gaming Monitor

Jackery Solar Generator 1000 v2 with 200W Solar Panel, 1024Wh LiFePO4 Battery

Bose QuietComfort Wireless Bluetooth Noise-Cancelling Headphones, Ice Blue
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Paper Ledgers to VisiCalc
Bookkeepers traditionally recorded transactions as debits and credits in a general ledger, then added and checked the accounts. For decades, the U.S. had roughly two bookkeepers for each accountant, according to the historical census and labor figures cited in the article. Computerized bookkeeping existed before personal spreadsheets, but the source describes earlier systems as large installations operated by specialists, rather than tools a business manager could readily use for an immediate calculation.
VisiCalc changed access to recalculation by putting a linked grid on a personal computer. Lotus 1-2-3 followed for the IBM PC in 1983. Levy reported in 1984 that more than a million spreadsheet programs were being bought annually in the United States, worth more than $250 million; those figures describe that period, not current software use. The source also recalls earlier calculating tools, including an abacus, to show that machines and methods for doing arithmetic have long affected bookkeeping tasks.
“I would work for twenty hours. With a spreadsheet, it takes me 15 minutes.”
— Don Jackson, accountant, quoted by Steven Levy in Harper’s in 1984
What Employment Figures Cannot Show
The employment counts show changes in occupational categories, but they do not identify how much of the decline in clerk numbers was caused by spreadsheets, accounting software, AI or other economic forces. The source does not provide a causal study separating those influences. Nor does the 2025 comparison show what individual workers did after jobs changed or disappeared.
The BLS outlook cited by the article is a projection, not a confirmed outcome: it anticipates a 6% decline in bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks and 5% growth in accountants and auditors by 2035. The source says the agency expects AI to handle routine tasks such as data entry without reducing overall demand for accountants. Actual employment may differ, and the supplied material does not specify how quickly businesses will adopt AI or how its use will change day-to-day duties.
Watch the 2035 Labor Outlook
The next benchmark in the article’s account is the BLS employment outlook through 2035. Future labor data can show whether the projected direction of change materializes, but they will not alone explain its cause. A clearer assessment would require evidence about adoption, task changes and hiring across accounting firms and businesses, alongside employment totals.
For now, the confirmed comparison is historical: clerk employment was lower in 2025 than in 1988, while accountant and auditor employment was higher. Whether AI repeats, accelerates or changes the effects associated with spreadsheets remains open. The projections provide a reason to monitor the work, not a settled account of what will happen to bookkeepers.
Key Questions
Did spreadsheets eliminate bookkeeping jobs?
No. The source links spreadsheets and accounting software with the automation of some bookkeeping tasks, but it does not establish that spreadsheets alone caused job losses. About 1.53 million bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerk jobs remained in the United States in 2025, according to the figures cited.
What changed in accounting employment between 1988 and 2025?
The cited BLS figures show bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks declining from about 2.25 million to 1.53 million. Accountants and auditors rose from about 963,000 to 1.60 million over the same period.
What does the BLS project for AI and accounting work?
The source reports BLS projections of a 6% decline in clerk employment and 5% growth for accountants and auditors by 2035. It says the agency expects AI to take over routine tasks such as data entry; these are projections, not confirmed results.
Does the employment trend prove AI is already reducing jobs?
No. The figures describe employment across past years, while the AI-related outlook is a forecast. The material does not quantify AI’s current effect or separate it from the effects of accounting software, spreadsheets and other economic changes.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
